I don’t know how old the liner I got was, but it was INCREDIBLY dry. It took forever to even try it just the once since it took so much effort (tapping, shaking, standing it up point down) to try and get any product out. Wasted money.

I’ve been trying to find the perfect liquid eyeliner for 6 years and this is it!!

awesome product

A while ago I ordered this in black. It was too light but I liked the way it glided on. This darker color is perfect. I am able to create a clean cat eye line with this eye liner. I do no wear a lot of makeup so I don’t have a lot of practice with application. This makes it easy for me.
Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum, Ultra Black, 0.016 Ounce